Contact Sheila

Appleton Office

4351 W. College Ave
Suite 310
Appleton WI, 54914

Telephone: 920-560-7063

24/7 Claims Reporting: 1-866-315-5103

10 Questions with Sheila Fenolio

What does the American Dream mean to you? 

My American Dream is to have the ability to make a difference.        

What does the Ansay Way mean to you? 

The Ansay Way is putting our customers first and serving their needs to protect their American Dream.        

In your personal experience, how does Ansay differentiate in the marketplace? 

We go beyond just providing insurance; we can help them find ways to manage their employees' well being and their bottom line.        

Why were you drawn to work at Ansay & Associates?

Ansay & Associates is a growing and thriving company in the industry. We are big enough to have many resources, but still treat all clients as an individual account.        

Give us a view into the company – what is it like working at Ansay? 

Ansay & Associates treats each of us like a person and a family member. We are not just a "number."        

Describe your approach to working with your clients.

I proactively work with them on their insurance program. I listen to their specific concerns and needs and then tailor a plan for them.        

What is one of your favorite client stories? 

It is when I become "one of them". I am not a salesperson that sells them something, but I have become part of their team, their work family. I walk into the office and everybody calls me by name.        

Do you have any area of specific focus in terms of industry or market?


What gets you out of bed in the morning?

Knowing what I do can help others be successful in what they do.        

What would your clients say about you? 

Sheila takes care of us.        

Do you have a favorite inspirational quote? 

It is not fair to ask of others what you are unwilling to do yourself. - Eleanor Roosevelt

Advisor Stats

  • 1983Insurance Career Started
  • 2006Joined Ansay Team
  • 384 LinkedIn Followers